Star Trek: The Motion Picture - The Directors
Edition (1979, 2001), Cert U. Director - Robert Wise. Writer - Harold Livingston. Starring - William Shatner, Leonard Nimoy, DeForest Kelly, James Doohan, George Takei, Walter Koenig, Nichelle Nichols, Stephen Collins & Persis Khambatta. |
Premise - The Enterprise is
rushed from it's refit to intercept an alien probe that is on a direct
course for Earth and is destroying everything in it's path.
That sounds quite exciting doesn't it? Alien probes, destruction, a refitted
Enterprise, so why is Star Trek: The Motion Picture so utterly boring and
tedious? There are many reasons, the major problem seems to be director
Robert Wise's attempt to make a space opera when what he should have been
making was a solid action/sci-fi flick.
Peppered throughout the movie are long, drawn out effects shots of various
space craft docking here and flying there. Every five minutes another one
seems to come along. This films want's soooooooo badly to be another 2001,
but it fails miserably. Granted the effects are quite good, especially
considering the age of the film. Star Wars employed similar use of motion
tracking, but at least that had something, anything happening.
At one point Scotty has to take Kirk to the Enterprise via shuttle. Kirk
asks why the transporters aren't working. Scotty spouts some nonsense
technobabble, but the audience knows the real reason why the transporters
aren't working. It's so we can be treated to another lengthy effects shot of
the shuttle taking forever to fly over to Enterprise, go all the way round
the thing before finally docking!
The ultimate in directorial self indulgence however comes when the
Enterprise enters the alien probe. In a scene that must last for ten minutes
we see the ship fly past several weird looking structures etc. No dialogue,
no acting, just a spaceship flying about.
The film was originally planned as a pilot for Star Trek: Phase 2. It was to
be the next series of Star Trek, but after Star Wars busted the block it was
quickly reshaped into a movie. Perhaps these numerous lengthy effects shots
have been added to try and pad out a story that was originally intended to
be only an hour long TV show?
The film also feels incredibly dated. The velour jump suits that the crew
are wearing just shouts late 70's at the audience. As do the dreadful synth
laden sound effects. Shantner's wig looks like it might take your hand off
if you get too close and Spock looks like he's been taking make-up tips from
Joan Rivers. In-fact, Shatner's wig might be a better actor than the man
himself.
Outside of Kirk, Spock and Bones the rest of the crew are reduced to a
couple of lines of dialogue and shaking about when the ship takes some
punishment. The rest of the crew are even further down the pecking order
than newcomers Decker and Ilia.
The plot is beyond hokey. Sure it's sci-fi, but when the main story is some
pseudo-mystical nonsense about an alien machine wanting to truly understand
human emotion you have to draw a line.
There are exactly two things I like about Star Trek: The Motion Picture. The
Klingon battle at the beginning and the music that accompanies it and the
transporter accident. That's it, the rest of the film is devoid of anything
positive from where I'm standing.
So what of the new fangled Directors Edition? Well, it's no better than the
original that's for sure. Some scenes have been added, some removed. Some
lines of dialogue have been removed and some special effects have been
touched up and some new effects scenes added. At the end of the day you have
to wonder why they bothered. If you're going to tinker with a film the aim
should be to come out the other end with a better movie, not one that's as
boring and tedious as the original.
It should be noted that I am a huge Trek fan, I just hate this movie. If you
want to see a good Trek flick go and rent Wrath Of Khan or First Contact.
2/10 for Star Trek The Motion Picture. Poster Quote - Star Trek: The No-Motion Picture. |