Heaven & Earth (1993), Runtime – 140mins, Cert
15. Director - Oliver Stone. Writer - Oliver Stone. Starring - Heip Thi Le, Joan Chen & Tommy Lee Jones. |
|
Heaven & Earth is
the final part in Oliver Stone’s so called Vietnam trilogy. Coming after
‘Platoon’ and ‘Born on the Fourth of July’, is quite and act to follow. But
Heaven & Earth holds it’s own and actually presents a very different movie
watching experience to the other two films, but with some of the same
overriding themes. Based on the memoirs (over two books)
of the real life Le Ly, Heaven & Earth shows us the Vietnam War from a
different perspective than that we are used to, that of a Vietnamese
peasant. It does teach us the same lessons though. War is hell, no-one ever
truly wins and it’s the innocents that get hurt the most. It’s the films
novel perspective though, that makes it so effective in teaching these age
old lessons about war. All the more effective thanks to the
startling central performance by unknown Vietnamese actress Heip Thi Le.
Barely off the screen for the films entire runtime, Thi Le basically carries
the weight of the entire film on her shoulders. A feat which she handles
effortlessly. The pain and suffering of the Vietnamese people is written all
over her face and she perfectly conveys a woman being torn apart by events
completely out with her control. It’s a bravado performance and I can only
assume that it’s the language barrier which has stopped her building on this
performance and carving out a successful acting career. Although the promotional material for
the film would have you think otherwise, Heip Thi Le really is the star of
the film, but the box does have Tommy Lee Jones plastered all over it. In
truth he doesn’t show up until a good hour of the film has passed. But, his
impact on the film is still huge. We know Jones is a quality actor, although
he could be accused of hamming it up from time to time. He is outstanding
here though. To start with his character seems
perfect, although some things he says reveal a darkness buried down deep.
It’s not until they move to America that we see the real Steve Butler.
Equally as affected by the war as Le Ly, Butler is a broken man, he only
knows one thing, to kill. When this is taken away from him he has nothing.
Not even the love of Le Ly is enough. Some of the later stuff from Jones is
truly amazing. Joan Chen plays Le Ly’s mother and is
almost unrecognisable behind an ugly set of black teeth. She has some really
emotional scenes with Thi Lee both at the start of the film and near the end
and all hit the right notes. As you would expect from Oliver Stone
the film is startling to look at with contrasting imagery littered
throughout the film. From the lush, beautiful landscapes and paddy fields of
the pre-war Vietnam to the harsh, brutal scenes of rape and torture. Stone’s
trademark style is a little subdued for this film, but this is still
unmistakably a Stone film. The first appearance of the US helicopter for
example, or the rapid editing on the black and white flashbacks, his
hallmarks are plain to see. I enjoyed the film most when it was in
Vietnam, especially the first 15 to 20 minutes before the US military show
up. I really liked seeing how a common Vietnamese family lives and works.
It’s something that you just don’t normally see in films about Vietnam. The
rest of the time in Vietnam is also very good. Where the film does falter
slightly is when it moves to the US. It all happens so fast that I got the
feeling that Stone wanted to make a 3 hour movie, but perhaps was under
pressure to make cuts. I would have welcomed that extra runtime if it
expanded on the Steve/Le Ly relationship a bit more. Giving us a better
insight into its development. The films epilogue tells us that Le Ly
went on to become a successful businesswoman in the US. This is hinted at in
the second half of the movie, but again isn’t expanded upon; I felt it would
have been nice to see the later stages of her life as she grasped it by the
horns and made her life and those of her people back home better. I did like
the scenes back in Vietnam near the end of the film though. Some very
touching moments between Le Ly and her mother and a very powerful speech by
Le Ly’s brother about the impact that the Americans had on the people of
Vietnam. In all Heaven & Earth is quite a dark
and depressing film, but then again the subject matter doesn’t lend itself
to cheery moments. It is however, a very powerful film that is at times
beautiful, shocking, moving and poignant. Boasting some wonderful
performances, Heaven & Earth paints a side of the Vietnam War that you have
probably never seen before.
Premise - Le Ly (Heip Thi
Le) is a peasant on a Vietnamese farm in the 50's, she’s content with her
life, her family and her land. Then an American helicopter lands and her
life is forever changed. The Vietnam War has started. Treated badly by both
the Vietcong and the Americans, Le Ly moves to Saigon and meets Steve Butler
(Tommy Le Jones). Will this American GI offer the peace she has sought her
whole life?
/10. See Heaven & Earth if you enjoyed – Platoon, Born on the Fourth of July, Apocalypse Now, Full Metal Jacket. Poster Quote – The yin to Platoon’s yang. |